That’s it, I have to get this off of my chest. As for the hordes of tween fangirls bearing torches and plastic vampire fangs? I can take ‘em. I will brandish literature at them and they’ll vanish.
I just read a film review comparing Twilight to the Harry Potter series, and I literally wanted to die inside. And it’s not because I am a rabid Harry Potter fan who dresses up on weekends and looks for Hogwarts during my free time.
It’s because J.K. Rowling can actually write a good story. Her world was so unbelievably well constructed and thoroughly researched and well-thought out, and it contains those delightful little details (like those great mythological connections that you don’t find unless you’re really looking).
Stephanie Meyer, on the other hand, writes the angsty world of the angst-ridden teenager. And it’s boring. It’s horrifically boring. After reading thirty pages of the main character’s self-indulgent moaning, I wanted to shoot myself in the head. I get that being ‘emo’ and having depressing feelings all the time is trendy right now, but really. Is there anyone out there really like that? If there is, I never want to meet them.
Which brings me to a character study. We have, on one hand, Harry Potter, who does get angsty from time to time. It’s a given in writing about teenagers. They’re just an angsty bunch. But does he complain all the time? Does he always meditate on how plain his features are? Does he moan ON AND ON AND ON for practically an entire series? And yes, Harry does play martyr occasionally. But he doesn’t GO ON AND ON ABOUT IT FOR INFINITY PAGES.
Bella. Not only is she a martyr (and a boring boring boring one at that), she’s a self-indulgent whining idiot. Her character cannot be feasibly realistic, because it has to be physically impossible to be so miserable in such a shallow, stupid way.
Don’t even get me started on how at least three boys fell madly in love with her within the first few minutes of meeting her, and she still feels ‘alone’. Gag me.
Basically, Meyer has written down the wet dream of a pathetic, angst-ridden generation who, instead of realizing that there is an entire world of suffering far more signifcant than theirs, would rather meditate on their ‘alone’-ness. And their ‘plain’-ness.
I also feel that Meyer is pandering. She knows what teenagers wants to read, so she writes that crap. I think Meyer has potential; her other characters are interesting and show depth. Bella has all the appeal (and personality) of a wet mop.
Meyer: grow a pair and write a good story. Stop worrying about pandering to a bunch of tweens and do your job as a writer: write the truth. And if your truth is Bella…God help you, woman.
I have another comment, more to express my incredulity at the sheer stupidity that is the character Bella than anything else. Later in the series, she is perfectly happy to become a vampire without a second thought, but she’s not sure she wants to be married. Uhm, I’m sorry…what? Last I checked, marriage was a far less permanent stage than IMMORTALITY.
I also happened to read that a lot of people thought Twilight was nice because it was a vampire story without any sex or violence, and there aren’t enough of those types of movies. Apparently, they forget that the entire legacy of the vampire is sex and violence. The vampire IS an emblem of sex and violence. Dracula, the vampire of vampires, was based off of Vlad the Impaler. He impaled people and then ate dinner beneath them. This is violent. Why did Stoker write Dracula? As I, and many literary experts, believe, Stoker wrote his novel to express his frustrated sexuality in while remaining within the confines of polite Victorian society. Basically, the part where the vampire drinks the blood is a metaphor for sex.
So, it’s kind of impossible to have vampires without the sex and the violence. Sorry.
To any Twilight fans reading this, I have two things to say to you before you go running for your capes:
1) Why?
2) Go read some real books. I don’t care if it’s Bronte, I don’t care if it’s Dostoevsky, I don’t care if it’s Steinbeck. Do yourself a favor, and enrich your minds instead of reading some manufactured drivel designed to be appealing. That’s not writing, it’s manufacturing.
I have been wanting to do that for SO LONG, and it felt SO GOOD.
And now I will go take cover from the fans.
Posted in Opinions
Tags: Bella, rant, Stephanie Meyer, stupid, Twilight